
Choosing a toilet seat might seem simple until you’re faced with dozens of styles, materials, and features. Whether you’re replacing a broken one or upgrading for comfort and cleanliness, Chatham Plumbing is here to guide homeowners in Chatham, Sarnia, and Leamington through the essentials of toilet seat selection.
Two Main Seat Shapes: Round vs. Elongated
Toilet seats generally come in two primary shapes: round and elongated.
- Round Seats are shorter and more circular, often found in older homes or smaller bathrooms.
- Elongated Seats are longer and oval-shaped, offering more comfort, especially for adults.
To determine the right shape, measure your toilet bowl from the mounting holes to the front edge.
Odd-Shaped Seats: A Special Case
Some toilets require model-specific or odd-shaped seats, which are typically more expensive and harder to find. These are usually custom-designed or brand-specific models that demand exact matches, so be sure to check your toilet’s make and model before replacing the seat.
Seat Closure Options: Slow Close vs. Regular
Today, homeowners can choose:
- Slow-Close (Anti-Slam) Seats – These close gently and quietly, reducing wear and tear and adding a touch of luxury.
- Regular Seats – More traditional and generally less expensive, but can be noisy and wear faster.
Easy-Clean Hinges: For Hygiene & Convenience
Easy clean hinges allow the seat to be lifted off the bowl with minimal effort, making it easier to clean those hard-to-reach areas. This feature is ideal for households prioritizing hygiene and convenience.
Foam Seats: Soft but Unsanitary
Foam toilet seats offer cushion-like comfort, but:
- Have a short life span
- Can become unsanitary over time due to cracks and fluid absorption
They’re best for temporary use or specific medical needs.
Moulded Wood Seats: Classic but High Maintenance
Moulded wood seats are:
- Heavy and solid
- Offer a traditional aesthetic
- Typically more expensive
- Have a shorter lifespan, prone to splitting and paint chipping
- Harder to keep clean, especially painted ones
These are suitable for those seeking a classic look and don’t mind the upkeep.
Composite Seats: Durable Yet Pricey
Made with a wood core and plastic lining, composite seats combine durability with aesthetic appeal:
- Heavy and solid
- Expensive
- More resistant to cracking than moulded wood
They are a good choice for households wanting a long-lasting, premium feel.
Plastic Seats: Affordable and Versatile
Plastic toilet seats remain the most popular for good reason:
- Less expensive
- Easy to clean
- Available in many colours and styles
They’re ideal for families, rental properties, and budget-conscious homeowners.
Final Thoughts from Chatham Plumbing
So, how do you select the right toilet seat? Start by identifying your toilet’s shape—round or elongated. Then consider comfort features like slow-close hinges and easy-clean designs. Evaluate materials based on durability, hygiene, and cost: plastic for affordability and cleanliness, composite for durability, moulded wood for aesthetics, and foam only for temporary comfort. Always be mindful of your toilet’s model to avoid costly shape mismatches.
Choosing the right toilet seat isn’t just about comfort—it’s about hygiene, budget, compatibility, and long-term satisfaction. Whether you’re in Chatham, Sarnia, or Leamington, the team at Chatham Plumbing is here to help you select the perfect fit for your bathroom.
Stop by or call today for expert advice and a full selection of toilet seats and plumbing supplies to suit your needs.
Need help choosing the right toilet seat? Contact Chatham Plumbing—your trusted plumbing supply partner in Chatham, Sarnia, and Leamington.
FAQs
- How do I measure my toilet to know which seat to buy?
Measure from the center of the mounting holes to the front edge of the bowl. - Are slow-close seats worth the extra money?
Yes. They prevent slamming, reduce noise, and extend seat life. - Can I install a toilet seat myself?
Yes, most models come with easy-to-follow instructions. Chatham Plumbing can help you find the right tools and fittings. - Why do painted wood seats wear out faster?
Moisture and cleaning chemicals can crack or chip the paint, reducing lifespan. - What’s the most hygienic toilet seat material?
Plastic is the easiest to clean and maintain, making it the most hygienic option for most homes.

